How Competition Structure Affects Trading Decisions

To trade well it is not sufficient to understand the balance sheet and finances of a company. It is not even sufficient to understand how a company may have performed in the past. To trade well it is important to be able to look into the future.

One of the things which good analysts look at is something called ‘Competition Structure’. This means understanding the forces of competition affecting a company and how that may change in the future for the better or worse. The investment community generally breaks these forces down into: ‘threat of substitute products’, ‘threat of new competitors’, ‘intensity of competitive rivalry’, ‘bargaining power of customers’ and ‘bargaining power of suppliers’. You can read more about that all here.

Entire books have been written about the so-called “five forces of competition” and there is already a lot on the web about this subject so I’m not going to repeat all that. Instead I will summarise a quick method for performing a similar analysis to help you come up with your own view of whether the company you like will continue to grow or not.

1. Sketch out the supply chain. This means understanding what goes on from start to finish in the production process.

Let’s take palm oil for example: In this industry there are upstream producers who grow and harvest the stuff, then there are downstream producers who operate the mills to process the fruit and then there are exporters and finally customers who buy it.

2. Figure out where your company fits into the supply chain. Sime Darby for example, owns plantations and mills and can be considered an upstream and downstream producer. CB Industrial however, supplies equipment for mills and can thus be classed as a downstream operator.

3. Understand the most important factors which will affect these forces. This is actually the hardest and most important part. A textbook example of this would be how IBM in the 80’s opened up its computer architecture to third parties and found itself having to compete against Intel for processors and Microsoft for the operating system, whilst Apple in contrast has kept its architecture pretty much under its own control and has not suffered in the same way. By trying to drive down its own costs, IBM inadvertently increased the threat of substitute products in its own industry and managed to decrease its own growth in an industry which was itself still growing.

In the context of palm oil, the main factors affecting competition are a) supply of land and b) customer preference. Diminishing availability of agricultural land on the peninsula has meant that planting has shifted to Sarawak and further to Indonesia. Also environmental concerns are prompting more and more customers to source palm oil from plantations that “have not been established at the expense of tropical forests”. And finally, there is of course the possibility that palm oil can be used as biofuel, which opens up an entirely new market.

4. Identify the industry life cycle. The life cycle of an industry can be split into several phases - pioneering, growth, maturity and decline (You can read more about it here). Green energy, for instance is in the pioneering phase, whereas the fashion retail business is in its maturity phase.

The palm oil industry, which began in Malaysia almost a century ago has created fortunes and allowed companies such as Sime Darby to diversify into property development, manufacturing etc. Therefore it can be regarded as an industry in its maturity phase. However, with the growth of demand for agricultural oils from India and China and the possibilities over biofuel, there is the possibility that a new phase of growth has occurred, much like the same situation regarding oil and energy. This helps explain the recent correlation which palm oil prices have had to energy commodities such as oil.

It is hoped that these four steps will help impose some structure into your analysis!

RSS feed | Trackback URI

Comments »

No comments yet.

Name (required)
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

PROUD SPONSOR OF

Stock Quotes

DJIA7997.28chart-427.47
000001.SS1983.76chart-33.71
^STI1613.95chart-51.64
^KLSE865.32chart-12.33
^BSESN8451.01chart-322.77
2008-11-19 16:06

Trading Tools - Reviews and Tutorials

Index

Company Scores

CSC Steel Holdings Bhd
csc-steel-holdings-ltd-14-09-08
KKB Engineering
kkb-engineering-bhd (10-06-08)
QL Resources
ql-resources(04-05-08)
Dreamgate Corporation Bhd
dgate08-11-07.pdf
YTL Corporation Bhd
ytl14-10-07.pdf
Opus International Group PLC
opus06-08-07.pdf
Notion Vtec Bhd
notion19-06-07.pdf
KFC Holdings (Malaysia) Berhad
kfc08-06-07.pdf
Pentamaster Corporation Bhd
pentamaster03-05-07.pdf
Adventa
adventa29-04-07.pdf
Kotra Industries
kotra-industries-26-04-07.pdf
Plenitu
plenitu04-04-07.pdf
YTL Powr
ytlpwr-26-02-07.pdf
Maxis
maxis17-02-07.pdf
DIGI
digi17-02-07.pdf
Petronas Dagangan Bhd
petdag-11-02-07.pdf
UMW
umw07-02-07.pdf
Genting
genting03-02-07.pdf
IGB Corporation
igb31-01-07.pdf
Topglove
topglov-31-01-07.pdf
IJM
ijm07-01-07.pdf
Gamuda
gamuda07-01-07.pdf
Dutch Lady
dlady19-07-07.pdf
Air Asia
asia11-01-07.pdf

RECOMMENDED READING

  • Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk
    Against the Gods: The Remarkable Story of Risk
    Author: Peter L. Bernstein
  • The Intelligent Asset Allocator: How to Build Your Portfolio to Maximize Returns and Minimize Risk
    The Intelligent Asset Allocator: How to Build Your Portfolio to Maximize Returns and Minimize Risk
    Author: William Bernstein
  • Key Management Ratios: Master the Management Metrics That Drive and Control Your Business (Financial Times Series)
    Key Management Ratios: Master the Management Metrics That Drive and Control Your Business (Financial Times Series)
    Author: Ciaran Walsh
  • Pring on Price Patterns : The Definitive Guide to Price Pattern Analysis and Intrepretation
    Pring on Price Patterns : The Definitive Guide to Price Pattern Analysis and Intrepretation
    Author: Martin Pring
  • How Countries Compete: Strategy, Structure, and Government in the Global Economy
    How Countries Compete: Strategy, Structure, and Government in the Global Economy
    Author: Richard H. K. Vietor
  • Fire Your Stock Analyst: Analyzing Stocks On Your Own (Definitive Guides (Financial Times/Prentice Hall))
    Fire Your Stock Analyst: Analyzing Stocks On Your Own (Definitive Guides (Financial Times/Prentice Hall))
    Author: Harry Domash
  • Trading in the Zone: Master the Market with Confidence, Discipline and a Winning Attitude
    Trading in the Zone: Master the Market with Confidence, Discipline and a Winning Attitude
    Author: Mark Douglas
  • The Secrets of Economic Indicators: Hidden Clues to Future Economic Trends and Investment Opportunities
    The Secrets of Economic Indicators: Hidden Clues to Future Economic Trends and Investment Opportunities
    Author: Bernard Baumohl
  • The Intelligent Investor Rev Ed. (Collins Business Essentials)
    The Intelligent Investor Rev Ed. (Collins Business Essentials)
    Author: Jason Zweig

RECOMMENDED LISTENING

  • Red Earth
    Red Earth
    Artist: Dee Dee Bridgewater
  • The Foley Room
    The Foley Room
    Artist: Amon Tobin
  • Immer 2
    Immer 2
    Artist: Michael Mayer
  • Hello Everything
    Hello Everything
    Artist: Squarepusher

RECOMMENDED FUN

  • Jim Cramer's Mad Money: Watch TV, Get Rich
    Jim Cramer's Mad Money: Watch TV, Get Rich
    Author: Cliff Mason
  • The Corporation
    The Corporation
    Director: Mark Achbar
  • Liar's Poker: Two Cities, True Greed
    Liar's Poker: Two Cities, True Greed
    Author: Michael Lewis
  • F.I.A.S.C.O.
    F.I.A.S.C.O.
    Author: Frank Partnoy